patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

5 Hurt in Series of Traffic Accidents; Man Revived After 4-Vehicle Crash

A four-vehicle accident at 159th Street and Oak Park Avenue injured three people Monday, including a man who was initially thought dead but revived at the hospital. Two other people were hurt in an two-car crash at 183rd Street and Harlem Avenue.

 

UPDATED: 2:41 p.m. Monday, Oct. 15

Three people were injured Monday morning after a four-vehicle traffic accident at the intersection of 159th Street and Oak Park Avenue, including a man who was initially thought dead but later resuscitated at the hospital, a Tinley Park Police Department official said.

That crash was one of a series of accidents in the Tinley Park area that also included a two-vehicle incident at the intersection of 183rd Street and Harlem Avenue, which injured two people, said Tinley Park Police Cmdr. Pat McCain. In both cases, officials reports had not been filed, and full details were still not available, McCain added.

The man, who originally had been reported as a fatality, was still being treated at an area hospital, McCain said. His condition was unknown but was thought to still be critical, he added.

Two other people from that accident were treated at an area hospital and released, McCain said.

Investigators were still examining the scene at 159th and Oak Park to determine the cause of the accident involving three cars and a Chevrolet Astro van, McCain said.

"By the time [investigators finish], they'll have a pretty good idea of what happened," McCain said.

Police and Tinley Park Fire Department rescue crews also responded to a two-vehicle accident involving a light pole at 183rd Street and Harlem Avenue. The two people in the crash suffered non-life-threatening injuries, and one woman was taken to an area hospital and released, McCain said. The commander was unsure if the other individual was treated at the scene or brought to a hospital.

These two crashes were just part of a series of accidents that happened this morning in and around Tinley Park. Two separate accidents along I-80 that involved five vehicles brought the interstate to a standstill.

A reader also reported an accident at 159th Street and Central Avenue in Oak Forest, and an ambulance was seen driving away from the area at around 9:30 a.m. However, Oak Forest Police said there were no reports around that location this morning, only a motorist assistance call at 159th Street and Ridgeland Avenue.

    Tinley Park rescue crews were responding to accident calls since 7:30 a.m., said Tinley Park Fire Department Chief Ken Dunn. He added that he wasn't sure why there were so many accidents this morning.

     

    Two Ways to Stay Connected to Tinley Park Patch:

    Related Topics: 159th Street and Oak Park Avenue, I-80 Accident, Injured Motorists, Tinley Park Fire Department, and Tinley Park Police Department

    Patty Z

    11:53 am on Monday, October 15, 2012

    It was just a matter of time before someone got killed at that intersection. My husband and I were just saying yesterday that something needs to be done about that exit from the car wash. It is so dangerous!

    Reply
    Comment_arrow

    John

    7:22 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    Patty, the accident is no where never the car wash. The pictures are being taken from Brown's Chicken parking lot or driveway. Maybe fried chicken caused the heart attack but I don't think Brown's or Delta Sonic have any accountability in the crash. Driving a car is dangerous and people need to be careful at all times. Get well soon van driver

    Comment_arrow

    Darnell

    7:15 am on Wednesday, October 17, 2012

    The van is resting against the signal box on the south east corner,,,far from the exit of the car wash! The car wash had no bearing on this accident!

    Dave

    12:02 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    Patty, you have a point about the car wash, but the accident is on the south side of the intersection looking at the photos here. So not near the car wash.

    Reply
    Comment_arrow

    Diane

    12:23 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    Looks to me like it's right outside the car wash, on the north side of the street. Either way, it's a horrible tragedy and my thoughts and prayers go out to all involved.

    Bonnie Bell

    3:24 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    I had to drive past this accident this morning on my way home from Meijer. It looked just horrific!! I pray the man thought deceased makes it.

    Reply

    Harry Callahan

    3:59 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    All these accidents in a matter of a little more than 30 minutes and in a pretty close area with injuries and a possible death was caused by some idiot behind the wheel,either the attitude of get out of my way,talking on the phone or texting or whatever,what the he$$ is wrong with our society today???

    Reply
    Comment_arrow

    O.F.D.

    4:33 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    You have no idea what the cause was, unless you were there. The article doesn't state that at all. I agree we all need to drive more carefully, some more than others, but you have no way of knowing that any of that was involved with this accident.

    Comment_arrow

    Bob Laird

    9:05 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    Harry, you did jump to a conclusion. If there was a medical issue, I hope everyone involved is OK. But you are right, I rack up 350 miles a week or so just driving to work and see what some people do. Whizzing by on the cell phone, cutting you off, and then giving you the evil eye or the bird cuz you're ONLY ten or fifteen over the limit. Don't know what caused this or the other events, but I'm sure that negligence was part of at least one. ivent/ butch will blame the banks or the government.

    Mary

    4:09 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    I drive to Midway Airport every morning from Crestwood. The things I see. I pray everyone is okay. But people really have to slow down and be a little more considerate of others. The speed limit is 35 the entire way. Just try to do it. You have to go at least 40 to keep up with traffic and people are still passing and weaving in and out of traffic. I don't know the answer but raising the limit isn't it. They'll just go faster.

    Reply

    Kathy Rogge

    4:53 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    That so called idiot suffered a heart attack while driving and is fighting for his life, thank you for your compassion Harry.

    Reply
    Comment_arrow

    Harry Callahan

    6:10 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    Kathy.I was talking in general about all these accidents happening with injuries and a possible death in a matter of such a short period of time in a close surrounding area,now I don't know were you got your info from,but I know for a fact the Tinley Park police were overwhelm by all these accidents besides the dispatcher getting enough manpower and rescue crews to the scenes,so before you start jumping on me,remember one thing most accidents like the ones that happen this morning are called accidents,but majority of the times they are caused by someones carelessness,so if you got some barking to do don't bark at me bark at the moon,because I didn't cause them.

    TP Karen

    5:06 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    I don't think Harry was saying that gentleman caused the crash, Kathy, but you have to admit when you look around while you're driving, way too often you see a driver texting or talking on a phone. It's usually the car driving over the line or driving irratically. I'd be willing to bet someone involved in that accident was not being totally focused on their driving!

    Reply

    Emma Long

    6:53 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    What time was the accident? we were passing it at about 845! did we just miss it ?

    Reply
    Comment_arrow

    Harry Callahan

    7:19 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    Emma, the accident on 159st and Oak Park happen about a few minutes before 8;;00am,they had two accidents on I80 about LaGrange rd at about 7'40am and then they had one happen not to long after the one on 159& Oak Park on 183 & Harlem,it was a rash of accidents happening in a short period of time and hampering police and rescue efforts also investigating on how these accidents occurred.

    Danielle Abendroth

    9:17 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    Harry i am not sure where you get your information from. How are you so sure a majority of accidents involve cell phones or whatever. Accidents are accidents. Yes tinley had a lot of accidents at once this morning but that has nothing to do with the causes. You have confused your topics. Think before you speak and get all your facts. An accident can just be an accident.

    Reply
    Comment_arrow

    Harry Callahan

    9:31 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    Your wrong,probably your a big offender of what I said leads to many of them,yes you have exceptions,but the majority are due to carelessness,but you and others commenting are looking for excuses ,like I told one commentor go bark at the moon not me ,I didn't cause them,and you are probably the first one to sue if somebody came along a tapped your butt,then its not just a accident.

    Comment_arrow

    TP Karen

    9:51 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    Danielle, what planet are you on? Have you not read or heard about cities, states, villages, etc banning cell phone use while driving. Accidents have causes...often human error. Ask any officer and he/she will tell you how often 'accidents' are caused by cell phones/texting or some other form of distracted driving!

    Comment_arrow

    Dave

    7:39 am on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    Danielle, I agree with you. A lot of the accidents I've seen haven't involved cellphones, but people not leaving enough space (remember the 2 second rule???). Paying attention or not, when you are 1 car length behind someone going at 40mph you are not going to stop in time. Also the excessive speeding. I annoy a lot of people going the speed I do speed limit or at times up to 5mph over. No accidents caused by me. I've been a victim of 2 accidents. One person was in a hurry who was beating a red light. People need to slow down a lot and give that reaction space. My sister was hit by a driver who didn't pay attention to the fact it was a 3 way stop. Also the other accident my sister's parked car was involved in was a pure accident. Mechanical problem where the tie rod broke and the driver lost steering. Actually I've seen another accident on I-55 where this was the case. A lot of accidents I've seen are from people being in a hurry. Granted distracted driving is a cause for a good amount, but plain old being impatient and speeding is another big cause (also uses up gas faster in your cars).
    Just for the record I've witnessed over 5 accidents, and been on the scene for probably 30-40 accidents. I'm one of the few people who stop to check up and help the people out and make sure emergency workers are called to the scene.
    Also, Tinley Park had a fluke of a lot of accidents in one day, not your typical day. A great job for the personnel who responded!

    Comment_arrow

    Bridget

    9:58 am on Wednesday, October 17, 2012

    Danielle: They teach you in driving class that people mistaking call a "car COLLISION" a "car accident." It is not an "accident" because it is caused by someone's carelessness or not driving for the conditions. So, maybe you should be the one getting all your facts straight before speaking. Look it up or visit the drivers education teacher at TPHS.

    Michael W Hof

    9:56 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    Accidents are Accidents stuff happens indeed. People need to slow down a little more. It's a combination of being in a hurry for no reason, and neglegence or driver error and distractions. Cell phones are a big problem also. Everything happening all at once is just a big coincidence to me. Now days there are more and more new drivers on the roads than ever before. Not everyone takes into consideration other drivers also. No matter how lawful you drive, or try to drive, people just don't care these days, and it's too bad more and more people are getting hurt because of carelessnes.

    Reply

    Heather

    10:49 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    The one on 183 & harlem happened to the car right behind me, at 9:50 a.m. (the 911 call on my phone was at 951). Had I hesitated I would have been the car that was hit. Unreal what a huge difference 3 seconds makes. I was the first to call 911, cops were there within a minute or two, great job to all teams in tinley today. Hopefully those drivers are ok, scary to see a car behind you one minute and slammed into a few seconds later.

    Reply

    Danielle Abendroth

    10:51 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    Harry once again you have made an incorrect ASSumption. Do i talk on the phone while i drive, yes. Does that mean im a distracred no. Cell phones can be a distraction and if texting etc then yes for sure. I do NOT text while i drive, nor do i sue if someone taps me, and im not sure where you or anyone else gets off passing judgment on me or anyone you dont know. Do you ever eat in the car while driving, or change the radio station or have a passenger in the car while your driving? Those are all distractions, I highly doubt you are a perfect driver and have never been a distracted driver. When the news of the story broke about the accident at 159&oak park a great number of people wrongly assumed that a cell phone aas involved when the man suffered a heart attack. When the kid got hit by the car on 151st people wrongly assumed a cell phone was involved.

    Reply
    Comment_arrow

    Harry Callahan

    11:05 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    I never said I was a perfect driver and do you know and others if the man that had the misfortune of a heart attack did he have it driving or after the accident,now do you want me to make a fool out of you and some others,Well do you???

    Comment_arrow

    Dave

    8:00 am on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    The really funny thing is, I see police officers using the cellphone a lot and not causing accidents. State troopers, county sheriff officers, AND city police officers. Granted I do have to admit, especially with younger less experienced (younger) drivers have issues with cellphones because they are sitting there reading an entire text or getting emotional on a phone call with someone.
    When I first started I was talking on the radio in the car, which has been used to call in a few of the accidents since this was before cellphones became what they are today (back when they were bricks and a fortune to buy).
    BTW only 1 accident out of the many I've been involved with (over 30 accidents total) was a cellphone incident. That is only 3% from my sample. At least 4 of them were medically induced (cardiac arrest, stroke, seizure related). 1 was someone reaching down onto the floor for something that he dropped. Over 10, speeding were involved. At least 3 were running red lights or trying to beat the red light.
    Distracted driving is on the rise mostly cause of the teenage drivers and the higher influx of them coming onto the road. Remember we have A LOT more drivers now than before meaning more opportunities for accidents.
    I said everyone needs to slow down and give that zone for reactions to AVOID the accident. Be an assertive driver, not a aggressive driver.

    Comment_arrow

    Jane Reader

    11:06 am on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    And it is a fact proven by research that talking on a cell phone uses 40% of your brain alone. Imagine that. 40%, not to mention the additional that's being utilized just to concentrate on driving (paying attention to the road and surroundings) itself. And your brain targets the phone conversation before the driving. Most people unknowingly decrease their speed by 5-10mph while driving and talking on the phone and they do swerve. Again, all backed by research which I'm sure you can google.

    The number one cause of accidents is cell phone use. Two is playing with the radio and third is eating (more stuff you can research). Before smartphones the number one was eating. It's fair to assume when statistics don't lie.

    Comment_arrow

    Dave

    12:00 pm on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    @Jane, are you using this webpage for your facts? http://www.nophonezonenv.com/facts.htm
    If so read the actual quote "Brain power used while driving decreases by 40 percent when a driver listens to conversation or music. (Center for Cognitive Brain Imaging at Carnegie Mellon University study)". No where did it single out cellphone if that is your case. The passenger next to you is just as much to blame in this "fact". The brain becomes active when in a conversation. Actually I prefer talking to someone than falling asleep at the wheel when doing 2 hour drives which I do regularly. Also statistics don't lie as many people say but then selective sampling can skew statistics. Especially if you have someone who is a advocate of a cellphone ban. Like how about all those ads you see with 9 in 10 doctors suggest this product? How come my doctor refuses, and then another doctor I know. That is 2 in 2. Using statistics to prove a point can get very dicey. I've found myself to be more dangerous of a driver when by myself on long drives than talking on a phone cause I'm actually aware of my surroundings. Maybe I have a better understanding of paying attention to the road. This is a debate that goes on within the ranks of our lawmakers and they get fed these statistics.
    As I mentioned before I'm a split on this. Personally I've seen less accidents involving cell phones than other issues. Maybe I'm just an outlier statistic. Same with me using the phone.

    Danielle Abendroth

    10:59 pm on Monday, October 15, 2012

    As for you Karen, I live on planet earth thanks for your rude judgment. Too bad you dont put your full name out to stand by your ignorant comments. Im sure like Harry you are a perfect driver and never do any of the things I mentioned. Accidents are called accidents, they are not called purposes. Sometimes yes people are distracted or under the influence or whatever, but again not every accident is caused by someone being careless or distracted. When accidents occur in the winter with snow and ice is that due to human error also? Have you ever driven somewhere and not even know how you got there because your mind is on autopilot. When i am talking on my cell phone that actually prevents that happening to me.

    Reply
    Comment_arrow

    Bob Laird

    7:09 am on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    A true accident can't be avoided. Someone having a heart attack behind the wheel can't be avoided. Driving in bad weather can't be avoided etc etc. Yakking on a cell phone, drunk driving, reckless driving CAN be avoided. You make a pretty poor case,

    Comment_arrow

    Dave

    8:11 am on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    Winter driving can be more reduced, or at least the severity of it with people who give more space and not drive recklessly for the conditions of the road. One example, done with college for the fall semester, heading home after finals it was a big snowstorm. Travelling from NIU in Dekalb to Oak Forest.
    At the point I packed up the car and got onto the road, about 3-4 inches had fallen in DeKalb. I-88 was a mess not even plowed yet. I ended up being the lead car with a caravan of cars behind me. You'd swear I was blazing a trail because there were few tire tracks in front of me. Average speed of 15-25 mph depending on straightaways vs turns. Every once in a while a car comes driving by me going probably about 30-35, about a mile or 2 down the road I see the same car slid off the road on a turn. I think it was 3 or 4 cars total that did this.
    The lesson of this true story is know the road, if you don't know how fast you can handle turns because of unsafe road conditions, slow down. It took me 4 hours to get home that night when it is normally 1.5 hours, 73 miles from parking lot to driveway. By the way, it was still heavy snow up until around Highland Ave (between I-355 and I-294) where it was switching over to rain/sleet.

    Comment_arrow

    Dave

    8:15 am on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    Another accident on the way home weather related because someone didn't pay attention to the road was black ice. 4 car accident, a 5th flies by me on a bridge while not paying attention to my flashers, hits the 4 car accident, I get through unscathed going around all 5 cars on the 2 lanes because well I was going 5mph cause I KNEW of the black ice caused from freezing rain. I was actually on the phone just minutes before but when i started noticing freezing rain affecting the roads and I know bridges freeze over before roadways. This was in Lemont, I think it was 2004 or 2005 on Lemont Rd. right over the triple waterway heading southbound. Again, caused from driving too fast for conditions (as I drove through the added accident scene and made it through without any incident).
    Weather related yes causes problems, but with the weather related, it still comes down to human decision to slow down for the conditions of the roadway.

    Danielle Abendroth

    6:53 am on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    My husband does work for both the OF and TP fire departments, and happened to be there yesterday. He was told that the crews believe the driver of the astrovan did in fact have a heart attack while driving which caused him to drive right through the intersection and hit the other vehicles. There you have it. Make a fool of me, come on.

    Reply

    Harry Callahan

    8:17 am on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    Thats what your husband said,is your husband a doctor,does he work at the hospital that the man was taken,you know people suffer heart attacks after the fact to.Listen all I did was comment on a rash of accidents in a short period of time that happen in Tinley Park,and commented on careless driving,and you are getting whacked out because I mention a cell phone,sounds to me your a accident ready to happen,and as you said your husband was there because he was a OF and TP fire dept.personal, Lets say I know what took place at the unfortunate number of accidents and injuries and probable causes ms. smarty pants.

    Reply
    Comment_arrow

    Danielle Abendroth

    9:02 am on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    And it sounds to me like your an idiot. Unless you were the driver or you were in the car with the driver than I really don't think you can know exactly what happened. How could you? Only the driver who suffered the heart attack or any passengers would know exactly what happened. And unless you were at every single accident (and how would that even be possible - how can you be at 3 different places at once, then you don't know what happened at all the accidents). And your right I am annoyed with you and all the other people who instantly think that cell phones are the cause of the accidents, not every accident is caused by a person using a cell phone, they can yes, but they are not always the cause and to rush to judgment on an accident is just wrong. You also misinterrpreted what I said about my husband, saying he is OF and TP fire department "personal" (your so smart you can't use the right word - it's personnel but whatever) implies he works for the city, but you would be wrong, and I never said he works for the city, I said he does work for those cities, which by mere coincidence was yesterday. I am not sure what that has to do with anything, he heard the cause directly from fire dept "personal", that was not speculation on his part, he merely relayed what he was told. Again noone can know exactly what happened other than the driver and/or passengers.

    Comment_arrow

    Dave

    9:24 am on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    Just a note here. There is a difference between cardiac arrest and a heart attack. It could have been detected as a cardiac arrest on site. Also, EMS crews usually find out what the outcomes of the ER visit was, usually helps in continuing education as EMS is always changing.

    Danielle Abendroth

    9:09 am on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    Bob - actually I would disagree, driving in bad weather can be avoided, maybe not all the time, but it can be. If I know that a blizzard is coming, I am not going to run out and drive in the middle of it. That would just be plain stupid. I would attempt to get home from work, the store, etc before that occurred. Also, if I was somewhere and there were tornado winds, etc, I would pull over if I was driving or not leave where I was at. If cell phones are so evil then they should just be banned all over the country. Too bad there are jurisdictions that must not believe cell phones are so evil. There is a difference between reckless driving (which I belive technically is driving in excess of 20 mph over the posted speed limit), drunk driving and cell phone use. I am perfectly able to maintain safe speed limits while talking on the phone and I have never gotten into a car accident while driving on the phone. Like the others I highly doubt that you have never been a distracted driver or that you have never gone one mile over the speed limit. Impossible. Also, what about those that go under the speed limit, that is also a hazard, noone has mentioned those people. Those who live in glass houses should not throw the first stone.

    Reply

    Harry Callahan

    9:28 am on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    Your the idiot,just read your comment on what your hubbie said,lady I think your some sicko or somebody that wants to g et under someones skin,all over a cell phone I happen to mention on a comment on the rash of accidents monday morning,lady if you are one you need help 10/4

    Reply
    Comment_arrow

    Danielle Abendroth

    9:52 am on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    Again. I do not take kindly to your judging my character or personality. What are you basing this off? Because I am standing up for something that I believe in, so that makes me a sicko? I know exactly what my comment said regarding what my husband said, I am not sure where the part that I am idiot comes along, because I relayed information that was given to him by the apporpriate "personal"? You're an ignorant moron. You're the one trying to get under peoples skin with your errroneous comments. I am still waiting for the part where you make a fool out of me and the rest of us who said the driver suffered a heart attack while driving, as well as your explanation as to how you could have known what happened at all 3 accidents yesterday. Hmmm, where are those at?

    Dave

    9:29 am on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    I do disagree about the driving too slow being a hazard. To make it more of a better statement, driving too slow in lanes other than the right lane is definitely a hazard, unless the conditions of the road/weather make it hazardous to drive at the speed limit (heavy rain, ice, snow, hail, sleet, fog). Remember there are minimum speed limits on the interstates. Excessive slowness is definitely a hazard but shouldn't be the cause of the accident on local roads. Drive out in rural areas (I mean REAL rural areas like the farming areas in central IL.). Get stuck behind a combine harvester on the roadway going 5 mph in a 55 mph roadway.

    Reply
    Comment_arrow

    Danielle Abendroth

    9:48 am on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    Of course driving under the speed limit for weather related reasons is an entirely different situation. The hazardous people that I am referring to are those that drive under the minimum speed limits on express ways and just in general. The people who drive under the speed limit on the roadways are more of a hazard to themselves then anything, but a hazard none the less.

    Patch_comments_icon

    Joe Vince

    11:50 am on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    @Danielle Abendrot and @Harry Callahan:

    You have an interesting debate going on (in fact, it's given me the idea about raising the questions you've brought up in a separate article), but please refrain from the name-calling. It undermines your arguments. At the very least, exchange email addresses with one another and go about lobbing your insults in private.

    Thanks,

    Joe Vince
    Local Editor, Tinley Park

    Reply
    Comment_arrow

    Dave

    12:32 pm on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    Thank you Joe :) Name calling just lowers your reputation especially when you are trying to debate an argument.

    Comment_arrow

    Harry Callahan

    12:39 pm on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    Listen I made a comment on the rash of accidents that occurred on monday morning and having some knowledge of what had gone on,and blamed one distraction that drivers have and that was cell-phones,the other commentor was the one that got nasty,took one thing and added another,this isn't the first time, and others that add on things like misspelling and other wise cracks,I'm only defending myself now if you want to police go ahead thats your right,but lets be fair about it okay.Theres more than 2 people making comments on this story.But I will refrain from name calling.Thank You.

    Comment_arrow

    Danielle Abendroth

    1:18 pm on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    @Joe, Mr. Callahan seems to have his timeline wrong regarding who started the mudslinging as excerpted from his post at 9:31 pm last night after my original post: "Your wrong,probably your a big offender of what I said leads to many of them,yes you have exceptions,but the majority are due to carelessness,but you and others commenting are looking for excuses ,like I told one commentor go bark at the moon not me ,I didn't cause them,and you are probably the first one to sue if somebody came along a tapped your butt,then its not just a accident." At any rate, I apologize for the name calling, however when people attack my characted for expressing my opinion, which is all I did, I get a little angry, nonetheless, I digress, I was wrong to escalate to name calling, I am a better person than that.

    Monica

    12:12 pm on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    Harry...its "you're" when you are combining the word YOUR and ARE, as in "You're the idiot." Calling someone an idiot, in a grammatically incorrect sentence...is pretty comical.

    "Driver distractions have joined alcohol and speeding as leading factors in fatal and serious injury crashes. The National Safety Council estimates 21 percent of all crashes in 2010 involved talking on cell phones."

    http://www.nsc.org/safety_road/Distracted_Driving/Documents/Cognitive%20Distraction%20White%20Paper.pdf

    Reply
    Comment_arrow

    Dave

    12:24 pm on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    NSC also says that hands free is unsafe. Well then if they decide to ban that, let's ban the kids in the backseat, the friend in the front of the car and music in the car. There has to be a compromise somewhere. I do a lot of public safety even while driving from the car. Casually talking to your friend next to you is just as dangerous because of the cognitive aspect of your conversation. As I said, statistics can and are driven to prove someone's point, especially if it is not a full population sample, and that partial sample can be manipulated.
    How about this explanation. Cellphones have become more common and the statistic doesn't show that the cellphone WAS the cause, just INVOLVED. Cellphones are more readily available, especially to younger drivers since they have gotten cheaper and are used for safety, too. Then there is USAGE. For example, I may not even be using my smartphone, but it is constantly sending data back and forth to the servers. I get in an accident, prove I was using the cellphone or not at the time of the accident. Looking at cellphone records will just show the data going back and forth. Now if you want to monitor/sniff/packet trace that data, that goes into privacy laws and I can think of several groups that would raise arms about having their privacy violated.
    As in the NSC's white paper intro, how do we know the driver would have noticed the red light if not on the cellphone (i.e. daydreaming).

    Comment_arrow

    Bob Laird

    12:52 pm on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    don't do a spellcheck on others without spellchecking yourself first. you're = you are, not your are.

    Comment_arrow

    Monica

    1:39 pm on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    HAHAHAHAHA! OHHHH that is coincidence at its BEST! Now its even more comical. YOU and ARE.

    I wasn't calling someone an idiot though. I mistyped....Harry just doesn't know the difference between your and you're. Which I normally wouldn't point out except it was in the sentence "Your an idiot." :-)

    ohhhh funny. oops

    Dave

    12:36 pm on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    Bleh, sentence fragments, forgot to read before I clicked submit.
    This argument is so up for debate no matter how you look at it. Both sides have valid arguments. Remember one thing that these action groups against cellphone use (handheld or hands-free) do not mention. The increased of the number of cellphones making them a higher supply to add into the statistic and there are more drivers. Remember years ago when I-294 had less lanes, and before the I-Pass system. It had less traffic issues. Then, more people got on the road, causing more traffic jams. They expanded the roadway to make more lanes and having the I-Pass to get tolls collected more smoothly. That worked for short while. Now, it's jam packed.
    These groups seem to neglect the other statistics of population and supply increases. I could probably write a paper on this and probably would if IL legislature tried banning all types of mobile communication devices (including radios). At least they exempted radio communication from the laws, for now.
    *edited to fix my few run-on and fragmented sentences*

    Reply
    Comment_arrow

    Danielle Abendroth

    1:21 pm on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    Thank you Dave for backing up most of my thoughts. :-).

    Bob Laird

    12:49 pm on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    It does get worse than anybody has posted here. This morning a woman drove around lowered railroad gates, killing herself and severly injuring her TWO children.

    Reply

    Monica

    1:30 pm on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    Dave, I agree with you 100%. I've always said many factors distract a driver...and cell phones are just one of them. Cell phones are just the easiest to point out, pick on, and ban. Distractions can include: Kids, an itchy butt, Sean Hannity, a DOG ON YOUR LAP (which by the way, was NOT banned recently,) my father's politcal rants, a sneeze, picking a big booger, smoking, manual transmission, no AC on a 105 degree day, hot leather seats....etc.

    We will never be able to curb all distracted driver accidents. To me I correlate this to to charging more for health insurance for smokers. It has been said that various unhealthy behaviors increase the costs to health care systems. Obesity is a major cause of morbidity and mortality and is associated with high medical expenditures. BUT charging smokers more is just EASY because it doesn't hurt anyones feelings....or call anyone out for being obese. When in reality, a healthy people cost more because they LIVE longer! Who knew? So technically we should be charging less for people who partake in unhealthy behaviors because they die younger. :-)

    (Although effective obesity prevention leads to a decrease in costs of obesity-related diseases, this decrease is offset by cost increases due to diseases unrelated to obesity in life-years gained. Obesity prevention may be an important and cost-effective way of improving public health, but it is not a cure for increasing health expenditures.)

    Reply

    Kellly

    2:06 pm on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    WOW!!! What a debate!! Well, reading all this has done one thing for me....it has for at least for a minute kept my mind off of my friend that was driving the astro mini van that did in fact suffer a massive heart attack which cause the accident. It's kinda sad though that the accident yesterday has led to the comments above.

    Reply
    Comment_arrow
    Patch_comments_icon

    Joe Vince

    2:14 pm on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    @Kellly:

    Thank you for your update. How is your friend doing?

    You can contact me at joev@patch.com if there's any information you would like to pass along or clear up but don't want to include in the comments section.

    Thank you again for your comments.

    Joe Vince
    Local Editor, Tinley Park

    Comment_arrow

    Danielle Abendroth

    2:56 pm on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    Kelly, so sorry to hear of your friend's unfortunate incident while driving. This article lost focus of that fact, which it shouldn't have. Whether its right or wrong, incidents like this will continue to be a hot button topic because of the opposing sides and varying opinions. Your friends accident just happened to be the catalyst for this week, through no fault of their own.

    nancy hullinger

    8:33 pm on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    THe Patch is getting more like Topix everyday!

    Reply
    Patch_comments_icon

    Lauren Traut

    9:27 pm on Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    It's unfortunate you feel that way, Nancy. Our sites are built upon a foundation of journalism and strong editorial leadership—something you don't see on Topix.

    Reply

    Darnell

    7:20 am on Wednesday, October 17, 2012

    Gotta just love all the traffic experts here!

    Reply

    S.Pike

    9:30 am on Wednesday, October 17, 2012

    I was once tailgated by a guy brushing his teeth.. all i could picture was him looking into his rearview mirror to see his teeth instead of my car right in front of him. I couldn't wait to turn into my neighborhood...

    Reply

    Harry Callahan

    10:51 am on Wednesday, October 17, 2012

    Monica , I'm trying to imagine you with a personality.Thank You and have a nice day.

    Reply
    Comment_arrow

    Monica

    1:39 pm on Friday, October 19, 2012

    Harry....I LOVE that you are imagining me. I'm touched.

    Volunteer

    2:16 pm on Thursday, October 18, 2012

    just so you know the man in the astro van is in very very critical condition and his family is at his bedside and it is not looking good. I think these comments should be deleted so that the family doesn't have to read them. You should not comment unless you know the facts about this family. All I can say is that the family needs all the prayers that they can get at this point in time. I think it is sad that people make these comments without knowing facts. They are truly good friends of mine and I am very hurt by all of these negative comments. Please just pray for him and his family right now.

    Reply

    Leave a comment