D122 Member Kathy Miller Pursues FOIA: Related Materials Per Ouster from Ballot

Kathy Miller refuses to amend her state court complaint, but civil matters are another story.

The latest action in the New Lenox School District 122 April Election comes today with a legal request for records from Board Member Kathy Miller's attorney.

The early January objection to Miller's petition sparked a firestorm that led to an outcry when she was temporarily kicked off the ballot and later put back by Will County Judge John Anderson.

But today, Miller's attorney filed a Freedom of Information Act request for all documents and other recorded information, including personal cell phones and emails, related to the filing of objections to Miller's petition. Specifically, the request names Board Members Maureen Broderick and Sue Smith. The request also lists New Lenox's Nikki Sanders for her role in presenting the objection as her own and the events leading up to the Jan. 11 Election Board hearing.    

Miller would not comment on the FOIA request, referring the matter instead to her lawyer. Attorney Mike Foley, of Chicago, said the FOIA requests specifically identified Broderick and Smith, both of whom were key in getting Miller kicked off the ballot for what has been described as minor clerical errors on her petition. Already, all related materials have been gathered from the school district, he said.

The FOIA request came as part of a statement in which Broderick is said to have "engineered the entire proceeding. Thereafter, contrary to the express advice of the Board's capable counsel, Ms. Broderick and her crony Sue Smith voted to strike Ms. Miller's election petitions. This required Ms. Miller to sue the Election Board in state court which in short order overturned Ms. Broderick and Smith's lawless attempt to fix an election…."  

The notary error on the petition was determined on Jan. 28

Patch has not received comments from Broderick or Sanders. However, Smith provided a statement.

"I am astounded that this attorney accused me of unlawfulness. I did nothing unlawful. I did my duty and I am fine with the outcome. As I stated before, this whole matter should go away so the board can focus on doing what we were elected to do.

"If Mrs. Miller and Mrs. Broderick  has a vendetta against each other and are willing to spend taxpayers' money to accomplish it, maybe they both should go way and let the board conduct the people's business."

Federal Court Matter

Foley said if the FOIA requests turn up questionable information, then the next step is a civil suit based on a violation of due process related to civil rights. The individuals named in the suit would be responsible to foot the bill, if Miller were to win. "We'll know soon," if there is evidence worth pursuing a civil matter against Broderick, Miller and Sanders.

The case would be heard in Chicago's Dirksen Building—United States District Court Northern District of Illinois.

Related Coverage:

  • D122 Union Asks for Support in Possible 'Unfair Labor Practices' Against Broderick
  • Judge Rules D122 Member Kathy Miller Back on April Ballot (UPDATE)
  • D122 Member Kathy Miller Kicked Off April Election Ballot
  • Anonymous Tip Led to D122 Petition Objection (UPDATE)
  • Candidate Petition for New Lenox School District Challenged; Hearing Set for Friday
  • D122 Board President Says Fellow Member Was Behind Kathy Miller Objection

Two ways to stay connected:

Ann Piasecki February 20, 2013 at 05:55 AM
Yes, Sue is Dave's wife.
Marie February 20, 2013 at 02:28 PM
I agree. I think both should resign rather than use our district as a political backdrop to a lawsuit. However, I doubt that will happen because then all involved wouldn't get as much attention.
JM of NL February 20, 2013 at 06:35 PM
Thanks Ann. No need to become like the Herald News forums. Let's keep it civil and productive. Even though our school board members can't.
Serge Storms February 21, 2013 at 02:57 AM
Thanks Kathy for dragging this out even more.....what is the name of the write in canidate? Oh yeah Todd Hyatt, yeah everyone remember that name Todd Hyatt, Todd Hyatt, Todd Hyatt, Todd Hyatt, Todd Hyatt, Todd Hyatt, Todd Hyatt,
Jon Voight February 21, 2013 at 04:19 AM
" crony"- LOL. Real legal-like.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »